What Is the Bow Tie Effect in Diamonds and How to Avoid It: Complete Buyer's Guide

You've found the perfect elongated diamond brilliant, elegant, and flattering on the finger. But when you look closer, there's an unexpected dark shadow cutting across the center, resembling a bow tie.

Should you be concerned? Is this a flaw? Will it affect the diamond's value?

The bow tie effect is one of the most misunderstood characteristics in diamond buying, especially for popular shapes like oval, marquise, and pear cuts. While it's a natural optical phenomenon not a defect understanding what causes it and how to minimize its appearance can mean the difference between a dull stone and a dazzling one.

At Ouros Jewels, we specialize in helping customers select diamonds with exceptional brilliance and minimal optical distractions. Whether you're shopping for an engagement ring or fine jewelry, this guide will empower you to make confident, informed decisions.

What the Bow Tie Effect Is (and Isn’t)

The bow tie effect is a dark shadow or band that appears across the center of certain diamond shapes, resembling a gentleman's bow tie. This optical phenomenon occurs when light entering the diamond fails to reflect back to the viewer's eye, creating a darkened area in the stone's face-up view.

Key Facts About the Bow Tie Effect:

• It's NOT an inclusion: The bow tie is not a physical flaw, crack, or internal characteristic graded on diamond certificates
• It's about light performance: The effect results from how the diamond's facets interact with light based on its cut proportions
• It varies in severity: Bow ties range from barely noticeable (adding character) to prominent (diminishing sparkle)
• It's viewing-angle dependent: The bow tie may appear more or less visible depending on lighting conditions and viewing angle
• It's NOT graded by GIA: Diamond certificates don't report bow tie presence or severity, making visual inspection critical

Important: The bow tie is essentially a shadow within the diamond areas where facets don't properly refract light back to your eye, creating the appearance of darkness.

The Bow Tie Severity Scale: Understanding the Spectrum

Not all bow ties are created equal. Understanding the severity levels helps you determine what's acceptable for your diamond purchase.

Mild Bow Tie (Acceptable)

Characteristics:

• Barely visible under most lighting conditions
• Only noticeable when diamond is tilted at extreme angles
• Does not impact overall brilliance or sparkle
• May add subtle depth and contrast to the diamond
• Often appears as a faint gray shadow rather than black

Expert Opinion: A mild bow tie is common in well-cut elongated shapes and is generally acceptable. Many jewelers consider this a natural characteristic that adds visual interest without compromising beauty.

Price Impact: Minimal to none these diamonds command full market value

Moderate Bow Tie (Borderline)

Characteristics:

• Visible in most lighting conditions but doesn't dominate the stone
• Appears as a noticeable gray-to-dark shadow across 20-40% of the diamond's center
• Reduces some brilliance but diamond still shows good sparkle
• Can be minimized with proper ring setting choices

Expert Opinion: Moderate bow ties are a judgment call. If the diamond is otherwise exceptional (excellent color, clarity, cut) and priced accordingly, it may be worth considering especially if you prefer the diamond's unique character.

Price Impact: 5-15% discount compared to bow tie-free equivalent

Severe Bow Tie (Avoid)

Characteristics:

• Prominent black or very dark shadow visible in all lighting
• Covers 40-60%+ of the diamond's center width
• Significantly reduces brilliance, making the stone appear dull
• Cannot be hidden by settings or lighting
• Creates a stark, distracting contrast

Expert Opinion: Severe bow ties indicate poor cut quality and should be avoided. These diamonds lack the light performance that makes diamonds desirable, no matter how attractive the price.

Price Impact: 20-40% discount, but still not recommended

Which Diamond Shapes Are Most Affected

The bow tie effect is exclusive to elongated brilliant-cut diamonds due to their asymmetrical proportions and facet arrangements.

Comprehensive Shape Analysis:

Key Takeaway: If you love elongated shapes (oval, marquise, pear), the bow tie effect is something you'll need to evaluate not avoid entirely. The goal is finding a stone with minimal or mild bow tie characteristics.

What Causes the Bow Tie Effect? The Science Explained

Understanding the root causes helps you identify well-cut diamonds that minimize this effect.

1. Light Leakage from Improper Facet Angles

Diamonds achieve brilliance through total internal reflection light entering the crown (top) bounces off pavilion (bottom) facets and exits back through the crown, creating sparkle.

In elongated shapes:

• The center section has longer pavilion facets
• If these facets are angled too shallow or too deep, light leaks out the bottom instead of reflecting back
• This creates darkened areas visible from the top the bow tie

Diamond refractive index: 2.42
Critical angle for total internal reflection: 24.4°

When pavilion facet angles deviate from ideal ranges, even slightly, light escape increases dramatically.

2. Poor Cut Proportions (Depth & Table Percentages)

Depth Percentage = (Diamond height ÷ Diamond width) × 100
Table Percentage = (Table width ÷ Diamond width) × 100

How depth affects bow ties:

• Too Shallow (< 58%): Light leaks directly through the pavilion, creating large dark areas
• Too Deep (> 68%): Light bounces internally but exits through the sides, not the crown also causing darkness
• Ideal Range (58-63%): Light reflects optimally back to the viewer's eye

3. Facet Symmetry & Polish Quality

Even with correct proportions, poor execution ruins light performance:

• Misaligned facets: Create uneven light distribution across the stone
• Poor polish: Reduces transparency and light transmission through facets
• Asymmetric pavilion: One side may perform well while the other creates shadows

GIA Grades to Prioritize:

• Polish: Excellent to Very Good
• Symmetry: Excellent to Very Good

Diamonds with "Good" or "Fair" grades in these categories are far more likely to display prominent bow ties.

4. Viewer Position & Environmental Lighting

The bow tie is a dynamic optical effect:

• Direct overhead lighting: Maximizes bow tie visibility
• Diffused ambient lighting: Softens bow tie appearance
• Viewing angle: Tilting the diamond changes which facets reflect light back to your eye
• Obstruction: Your head/body blocking light sources can enhance the shadow

This is why you must view diamonds under multiple lighting conditions before purchasing.

Does the Bow Tie Effect Impact Diamond Value?

Yes, but it depends on severity.

Price Impact Analysis:

Real-World Price Example:

Scenario: 2.00 ct Oval Diamond, G color, VS2 clarity

• No bow tie / Excellent cut: $15,000
• Mild bow tie: $14,500 (3% discount)
• Moderate bow tie: $12,500 (17% discount)
• Severe bow tie: $10,000 (33% discount)

Should you buy a discounted bow tie diamond?

Consider it IF:

• The bow tie is mild and doesn't bother you
• Other specs (color, clarity) are exceptional
• You're getting a significant price break
• You plan to keep the ring forever (not resell)

Avoid it IF:

• The bow tie is moderate to severe
• It visibly reduces the diamond's brilliance
• You're buying as an investment
• The discount doesn't feel substantial enough

Negotiation Tip: If you love a diamond with a moderate bow tie, use this as leverage to negotiate 15-20% off the asking price. Jewelers know bow ties reduce desirability.

How to Identify Bow Ties When Shopping for Diamonds

Diamond certificates (GIA, AGS, IGI) do not report bow tie presence or severity. This makes visual inspection critical.

Shopping In-Person: Expert Inspection Checklist

Step 1: Request Multiple Lighting Conditions

• Natural daylight (window light)
• Soft ambient room lighting
• Direct spotlighting (jewelry store display lights)
• Rotate the diamond 360° under each condition

Step 2: Use the "Hand Movement Test"

• Hold the diamond at arm's length
• Slowly tilt it side to side
• A severe bow tie will remain dark; a mild one will flash and disappear

Step 3: Compare Side-by-Side

• Ask to see 2-3 similar diamonds
• Compare how light moves through each stone
• The brightest, most even light return = best cut

Step 4: Ask the Jeweler Directly "Does this diamond have a bow tie, and how would you rate its severity?"

Reputable jewelers will be honest about this.

Shopping Online: Digital Evaluation Strategy

Step 1: Prioritize Retailers with HD Video

• Static photos can hide bow ties through clever lighting/angles
• 360° video reveals how the diamond performs as it moves
• Look for darkness across the center in any frame

Step 2: Check Depth & Table Percentages Use the chart below (next section) to screen out poorly proportioned stones before viewing videos.

Step 3: Request Additional Media Email customer service: "Can you send a cell phone video of this diamond in natural lighting? I want to evaluate light performance before purchasing."

Most online retailers will accommodate this if they refuse, that's a red flag.

Step 4: Use Virtual Consultation Services At Ouros Jewels, we offer virtual appointments where our experts will:

• Show you diamonds live via video call
• Discuss bow tie presence candidly
• Compare multiple stones in real-time
• Help you find the perfect balance of beauty and value

[Book Your Virtual Diamond Consultation]

Ideal Proportions to Avoid Bow Ties

This is the most actionable data competitors are missing. Use these ranges to screen diamonds before viewing them.

Comprehensive Proportion Guidelines by Shape:

OVAL DIAMONDS

Pro Tip: Ovals with ratios above 1.50 (long and skinny) show more prominent bow ties. Ratios between 1.35-1.45 offer the best balance of elegance and light performance.

MARQUISE DIAMONDS

Pro Tip: Marquise diamonds are the most prone to severe bow ties. Never compromise on Excellent polish and symmetry grades for this shape.

PEAR DIAMONDS

Pro Tip: Pear diamonds with excellent symmetry show more balanced light distribution, minimizing the bow tie around the center curve.

HEART DIAMONDS

Pro Tip: Heart shapes need near-perfect 1:1 ratio to minimize bow ties. Elongated hearts (> 1.10 ratio) almost always show prominent shadows.

RADIANT DIAMONDS

Pro Tip: Radiants have modified brilliant corners that help reduce bow ties, making them more forgiving than ovals or marquise.

Symmetry Grades to Avoid for Elongated Shapes

According to GIA grading standards:

Why symmetry matters: Misaligned facets create uneven light paths. Even a 1-2° angle deviation in critical pavilion facets can turn a mild bow tie into a severe one.

Natural vs. Lab-Grown Diamond Comparisons

Do lab grown diamonds have bow ties?

Yes, lab grown diamonds exhibit the same bow tie effect as natural diamonds.

Why Both Types Show Bow Ties:

Both natural and lab grown diamonds:

• Have identical chemical composition (pure carbon)
• Share the same crystal structure (cubic)
• Are cut using the same techniques and equipment
• Follow the same optical physics (refractive index 2.42)

The bow tie is a function of CUT QUALITY, not origin.

Key Differences:

Lab-grown advantage: Because lab diamonds are less expensive, you can more easily afford to be selective and choose only stones with minimal bow ties and excellent cut grades.

Natural diamond advantage: Long-term value retention and rarity for investment purposes.

At Ouros Jewels, we offer lab grown diamonds, all hand-selected for optimal light performance and minimal to no bow tie presence.

How Ring Settings Can Minimize Bow Tie Visibility

Even if your diamond has a mild to moderate bow tie, the right setting can significantly reduce its visibility.

Best Settings to Minimize Bow Ties:

1. Halo Settings (Most Effective)

How it works:

• Surrounding diamonds in halo setting create additional light sources
• Light enters the center stone from all angles
• Brilliance from halo diamonds "fills in" the bow tie shadow
• Creates the illusion of a brighter, whiter center

Recommendation: Choose a micro-pavé halo with 0.01-0.02 ct diamonds for maximum light diffusion.

2. Three-Stone Settings (Moderate Effectiveness)

How it works:

• Side stones in three stone setting draw attention away from center stone's bow tie
• Creates movement and sparkle across the entire ring
• Balanced visual weight reduces focus on any single area

3. Prong Settings (Lower Effectiveness)

How it works:

• Maximum light entry from all sides
• No obstruction from metal
• Prong setting are best for diamonds with minimal bow ties

Caution: Prong settings don't hide bow ties they can actually make moderate/severe ones more visible by allowing unobstructed viewing.

4. Bezel Settings (Lower Effectiveness)

How it works:

• Metal rim around the diamond's edge in bezel setting reflects light back into the stone
• Reduces contrast between bow tie shadow and bright areas
• Creates a softer, more blended appearance

Best for: Moderate bow ties that need visual softening

Metal Color Considerations:

Complete Buying Checklist: Avoid Bow Ties Like a Pro

Use this checklist to screen and evaluate diamonds systematically:

SCREENING PHASE (Before Viewing)

•  Check diamond shape: Is it oval, marquise, pear, heart, or radiant?
•  Verify depth percentage: Within ideal range for the shape?
•  Verify table percentage: Within ideal range for the shape?
•  Check length/width ratio: Within recommended range?
•  Confirm symmetry grade: Excellent or Very Good?
•  Confirm polish grade: Excellent or Very Good?
•  Request HD video or images: Can you see the diamond from multiple angles?

If any answer is NO → Request alternative stones

VISUAL EVALUATION PHASE

•  View in natural daylight: Is there a dark shadow across the center?
•  View in soft ambient lighting: Does the shadow remain prominent?
•  View under direct spotlighting: How intense does the bow tie appear?
•  Perform the tilt test: Does the shadow flash or remain dark?
•  Compare side-by-side: Is this diamond brighter than alternatives?
•  Ask expert opinion: What severity level would they assign?

Rate the bow tie: Mild / Moderate / Severe

DECISION PHASE

If BOW TIE is MILD: Proceed with purchase if other specs meet your criteria

If BOW TIE is MODERATE: Negotiate 10-20% discount
Consider halo setting to minimize visibility
Only proceed if you genuinely love the stone

If BOW TIE is SEVERE: Request alternative stones
Do not purchase compromised light performance

SETTING SELECTION PHASE

•  Mild bow tie: Any setting works prioritize personal style
•  Moderate bow tie: Choose halo, bezel, or three-stone setting
•  Excellent cut with no bow tie: Showcase in simple prong setting

Quick Decision Guide: Should You Buy This Diamond?

SCENARIO 1: Minimal/No Bow Tie + Excellent Proportions

Decision: ✅ BUY
Why: This is what you're looking for excellent light performance
Action: Proceed with any setting style you love

SCENARIO 2: Mild Bow Tie + Very Good Proportions + Great Price

Decision: ✅ CONSIDER
Why: Acceptable if priced fairly and doesn't bother you visually
Action: View in multiple lighting conditions; choose complementary setting

SCENARIO 3: Moderate Bow Tie + Good Proportions + Deep Discount

Decision: ⚠️ MAYBE
Why: Only if discount is 15%+ and you're designing a halo setting
Action: Negotiate further; visual inspection is mandatory

SCENARIO 4: Severe Bow Tie + Any Proportions + Any Price

Decision: ❌ PASS
Why: Compromised brilliance not worth it at any price
Action: Request alternative stones immediately

Real-World Diamond Report Examples

Let's analyze actual GIA reports to see how specifications translate to bow tie risk:

Example 1: Well-Cut Oval (Minimal Bow Tie)

GIA Report #: [Hypothetical] 2234567890

• Shape: Oval Brilliant
• Carat: 1.50 ct
• Color: F
• Clarity: VS1
• Measurements: 9.45 × 6.82 × 4.15 mm
• Depth: 60.8% (Ideal range)
• Table: 58% (Ideal range)
• Length/Width Ratio: 1.39 (Ideal range)
• Polish: Excellent 
• Symmetry: Excellent

Analysis: All proportions within ideal ranges. Excellent polish and symmetry ensure optimal facet alignment. Expected bow tie: Minimal to none.

Market Value: $12,500-$13,500

Example 2: Problematic Oval (Severe Bow Tie)

GIA Report #: [Hypothetical] 2234567891

• Shape: Oval Brilliant
• Carat: 1.50 ct
• Color: F
• Clarity: VS1
• Measurements: 9.85 × 6.35 × 3.88 mm
• Depth: 61.1% (Acceptable but paired with problematic ratio)
• Table: 62% (Acceptable)
• Length/Width Ratio: 1.55 (High end increased risk)
• Polish: Very Good 
• Symmetry: Good (Red flag)

Analysis: "Good" symmetry + elongated ratio (1.55) = High bow tie risk. Even though depth/table are technically acceptable, the combination of factors indicates poor light performance.

Expected bow tie: Moderate to Severe.

Market Value: $9,500-$10,500 (15-20% discount due to bow tie)

FAQs: Everything Else You Need to Know

1) Can you fix or remove a bow tie in a diamond?

Ans: No, not without recutting the stone.
The only way to eliminate a bow tie is to repolish the diamond with corrected pavilion facet angles. However:

• Recutting reduces carat weight (typically 10-20% loss)
• Cost of recutting: $500-$2,000+
• Risk of damage during recutting
• Not economically viable in most cases

Better approach: Choose a well-cut diamond from the start.

2) Do antique diamonds have bow ties?

Ans: Yes antique diamonds can exhibit bow ties, especially:

• Old Mine Cut ovals
• Antique marquise cuts
• Victorian-era pear shapes

Key difference: Antique diamonds were hand-cut by candlelight, so proportions vary widely. Bow ties in antique diamonds are more accepted and expected as part of their historical charm.
If purchasing an antique diamond, evaluate the bow tie's severity the same way but understand it's part of the stone's character and history.

3) Is a diamond with a bow tie less durable or valuable long-term?

Ans: Durability: No the bow tie doesn't affect physical structure or durability. It's purely optical.

Value: Yes diamonds with severe bow ties:

• Sell for 20-40% less initially
• Are harder to resell (30-50% penalty)
• Appeal to a smaller market

Mild bow ties have minimal long-term value impact.

4) Do other gemstones have bow tie effects?

Ans: Yes! The bow tie effect appears in:

• Sapphires (oval, pear, marquise cuts)
• Rubies (elongated shapes)
• Emeralds (though less common due to step-cut faceting)
• Moissanite (lab-created diamond alternative)
• Aquamarine (elongated cuts)

The same principles apply: elongated brilliant cuts are most susceptible.

5) Can lighting in my home hide a bow tie?

Ans: Partially, but not reliably.

• Diffused overhead lighting: Softens bow tie appearance
• Direct sunlight: Makes bow ties more visible
• Low-light environments: Diamonds lose sparkle, but bow ties remain present

You cannot "light design" your way out of a severe bow tie. Choose a well-cut diamond instead.

6) Are there any fancy shapes that DON'T have bow ties?

Ans: Yes shapes with symmetrical proportions:

1. Round Brilliant: Perfect symmetry eliminates bow ties
2. Princess Cut: Square shape with balanced faceting
3. Asscher Cut: Step-cut square with equal dimensions
4. Emerald Cut: Rectangular step-cut with hall-of-mirrors effect
5. Cushion Cut (Square): Balanced proportions when length/width is close to 1:1

If you want to avoid bow tie concerns entirely, choose one of these shapes.

7) Can I see bow ties in diamond photos online?

Ans: Sometimes but photos can be misleading.

• Professional photography uses optimal lighting to minimize bow tie visibility
• Static images don't show how the diamond performs when moving
• Retouching can hide or soften bow ties

Always request 360° HD video to see the diamond's true light performance.

Why Choose Ouros Jewels for Your Diamond Purchase?

Ans: At Ouros Jewels, we understand that buying a diamond is a significant investment emotionally and financially. That's why we're committed to transparency, education, and helping you find a stone with exceptional brilliance.

Ouros Jewels Commitment to You:

1. Hand-Selected Diamonds: Every diamond in our inventory is visually inspected for bow tie presence and overall light performance
2. Honest Expert Guidance: We'll never sell you a diamond with a severe bow tie even if it means recommending a lower-priced stone
3. Custom Design Services: Our designers work with you to create settings that complement your diamond's unique characteristics
4. Virtual Appointments: Can't visit in person? Book a virtual consultation where we'll show you diamonds live and answer all your questions
5. No-Pressure Shopping: Take your time, ask questions, and make informed decisions without sales pressure
6. Lifetime Services: Complimentary cleaning, inspection, and maintenance for the life of your jewelry

Book Your Virtual Diamond Consultation

Ready to find your perfect diamond? Our experts will:

1. Show you multiple diamonds side-by-side
2. Discuss bow tie presence candidly
3. Explain proportions and light performance
4. Help you choose the best value for your budget
5. Design a custom ring that brings your vision to life

[Schedule Your Free Virtual Appointment]

Prefer to visit in person?
📍 Ouros Jewels Showroom
USA: 30 W 47th St STE 204, New York, NY 10036
UK: 107-111 Fleet St, London EC4A 2AB, United Kingdom

Conclusion: Make a Confident, Informed Decision

The bow tie effect doesn't have to be a dealbreaker but understanding what it is, how to evaluate it, and when it becomes problematic is essential for buying a diamond you'll love forever.

Key Takeaways:

• The bow tie is an optical shadow caused by light leakage, not a physical flaw
• It ranges from mild (acceptable) to severe (avoid)
• Elongated shapes (oval, marquise, pear) are most affected
• GIA certificates don't report bow ties visual inspection is mandatory
• Ideal depth, table, and symmetry grades minimize bow tie risk
• Moderate bow ties can be negotiated for 10-20% discounts
• The right setting (especially halo) can reduce bow tie visibility
• Never compromise on cut quality to save money 

At Ouros Jewels, we're here to guide you through every step of the diamond-buying journey. Whether you're searching for an engagement ring, anniversary gift, or custom jewelry piece, our team is committed to helping you find a stone that truly sparkles without distracting shadows.

Ready to start your diamond search?

👉 Browse Our Diamond Collection
👉 Book a Virtual Consultation
👉 Explore Custom Ring Designs